In the deepest, darkest parts of our oceans live creatures that have mastered bioluminescence. Out of all these creatures and their colourful displays, what makes it so challenging to find species that emit light in the deep-blue region?
Dr Masahito Oh-e at National Tsing Hua University in Taiwan, together with his collaborator Dr Akira Nagasawa, Professor Emeritus of Saitama University in Japan, uses computational chemistry modelling approaches to investigate.
Read the original article: https://doi.org/10.1021/acs.organomet.0c00506
Read more in Research Outreach
Image credit: Richard A McMillin/Shutterstock
Hello and welcome to Research Pod. Thank you for listening and joining us today.
In this episode we will be looking at the research of Dr Masahito Oh-e at National Tsing Hua University in Taiwan. Together with his collaborator Dr Akira Nagasawa, Professor Emeritus of Saitama University in Japan, he is using modelling approaches to understand exactly what makes it so challenging to find species that emit light in the deep-blue region with high efficiency and, for those compounds that do, exactly how they generate such colours.
In the deepest, darkest parts of our oceans live some strange and exotic creatures that have mastered combining chemistry with light. No natural light from the sun reaches these depths, but thanks to the chemical skills of the fish, bacteria and crustaceans that live there, there are often eerie and ethereal light shows to be enjoyed.
These sea creatures are experts in bioluminescence. By using special compounds that will light up when they react, these animals can create brilliant displays of light to dazzle and confuse predators, lure in prey and attract mates. For many animals, the step in the bioluminescence process that leads to the emission of light is known as phosphorescence or fluorescence. The more efficient this emission process is, the brighter is the light that is emitted.
Humans also try to make use of emission processes in lighting and display technologies, such as those based on organic light-emitting diodes, also called OLEDs. Here, it is key that the luminescence process is very efficient, so the light emitted is very strong but also that the wavelength of light emitted falls within the correct ranges. Getting the right spectrum emitted from each of the compounds in the OLED is essential so that the light has the right colour properties for the application. This is particularly challenging if the desired colours are in the deep-blue region of the spectrum for organic materials.
Not all chemical compounds show evidence of luminescence, let alone with sufficient intensities so that they can be used in various applications. Of the molecules that do emit, though, changing the chemical structure or the atoms in the molecule can have a profound effect on the colours of light emitted and how efficiently luminescence occurs.
Understanding how to tune the luminescence properties by switching chemical groups is a challenging task and one at the heart of Dr Masahito Oh-e’s research at National Tsing Hua University in Taiwan. Dr Oh-e conducted his research in collaboration with Dr Akira Nagasawa, Professor Emeritus of Saitama University in Japan.
How do the researchers create novel complexes that efficiently emit deep-blue luminescence using a metal complex?
Organic substances are based on carbon and have certain structures, properties, and functions. New types of structures, properties, and functions can be achieved by combining organic substances with metal elements to form novel complexes. In the research presented here, the luminescence itself is derived from the metal-organic bond in the molecule.
Dr Oh-e’s research involves using computational modelling to understand the influence of different chemical groups on the luminescent properties of compounds. He utilises such methods to consider necessary conditions for deep-blue luminescence while evaluating large numbers of molecules. Some of these molecules have already been made and measured while others are new, virtual, potential molecules that may produce deep-blue light. By bringing together large datasets like this, Dr Oh-e is able to identify trends in how certain chemical groups influence the luminescent behaviour of the overall compounds.
The computational methods Dr Oh-e uses allow him to pinpoint how the electrons move through a molecule. One of the most widely used families of compounds for luminescence applications are metal complexes based on iridium. These compounds have an iridium atom at the centre that is surrounded by different collections of other atoms, forming what are called ligands. The overall shape and structure of the complex is determined by how many ligands are attached to the metal centre and how large and bulky each of those is.
When molecules interact with light, the electromagnetic field of the light disturbs some of the electrons in the molecule and causes them to move. Dr Oh-e considers the degree of movement as a guiding indicator to understand luminescence mechanisms in the deep-blue region. If the molecule absorbs energy from the light, this forms what is known as an excited state, which is inherently unstable. Once the molecule has been excited like this, it will try to find a way to get rid of this excess energy and return to its original state. One way of doing this is luminescence – emitting energy in the form of light. In electronic devices, similar excitations to those triggered by light can be caused using a voltage bias.
Dr Oh-e has been trying to calculate how different ligands and metals influence the way the electrons move upon excitation, while considering why potential deep-blue luminescence is often not compatible with high emission efficiency. Ultimately, the amount of energy the emitted light has determines its colour, and how the electrons move and relax while competing with some relaxation pathways before luminescence influences how much energy is left over for this final step and how efficient it will be.
Advancing the a posteriori quest for deep-blue luminescence
For emitted light to be in the deep-blue region of the spectrum, there needs to be a large amount of energy left for the luminescence process. For higher yield of deep blue, Dr Oh-e has been paying attention to how readily electrons move from the metal to ligands via the metal-organic bonds in a metal complex. By bringing together large datasets of calculated compounds including virtual compounds, he has identified a trend regarding the amount of energy for the luminescence process and the degree of how electrons move from the metal to ligands in complexes. The larger the amount of energy left over, the less the electron can effectively move from the metal to ligands, which means that deep-blue luminescence becomes less efficient. However, Dr Oh-e has noted that, in his a posteriori method, not all of the calculated compounds can necessarily be synthesised or will even be emissive. Even if a compound can be synthesised and is emissive, a large amount of electron movement from the metal to ligands may not result in efficient emission.
Dr Oh-e points out that when metal complexes are designed for deep-blue luminescence, electrons move from the metal to ligands while carrying a large amount of energy. But these are not the only electrons that move. Other electrons that are originally located on the ligands surrounding the metal also move within the ligands. The electrons from the metal and ligands eventually admix and end up finding some different stabilised states. This admixture of electrons effectively hinders the movement of electrons from the metal to ligands. Further, this initial electron movement leads to the possibility of forming additional stabilised states as well as energetic deactivation from the excited state. A delicate balance of these energetic states is important, and they often create alternative energetic relaxation routes that compete with luminescence. This tendency becomes remarkable when pursuing deep-blue luminescence. These are the reasons why the efficiency of deep-blue luminescence may suffer.
Why are iridium-based complexes suitable for this type of luminescence?
Dr Oh-e has also been comparing how the luminescence properties of individual complexes change when the central iridium ion is replaced by another metal ion that has the same electronic structure. Different metal ions donate or take electrons with different efficiencies, which means replacing the central ion with another is equivalent to changing the balance of energy between the metal ion and ligand fragments. Replacing the iridium ion with different metal ions drastically alters the interactions with the ligands because of the difference in the relative energy levels between the metal ions and ligands. The balance of energy states between the central metal ion and ligands is indeed crucial, and the iridium ion has a suitable energy balance with the surrounding molecules for potential deep-blue luminescence while forming complexes with various ligands.
With such models, Dr Oh-e has been able to systematically survey the success or failure of deep-blue luminescence via a guiding indicator: the degree of electron movement from the metal to ligands. This might help evaluate promising target complexes in the ongoing quest to innovate materials with deep-blue luminescence. This type of a posteriori quest for deep-blue luminescence would help the search for materials that satisfy specific requirements. This indicator also provides a platform for discussing the intricate factors that may hinder the desired results while advancing the a posteriori quest for the dream of efficient deep-blue luminescence of an organometallic compound.
A different kind of luminescence mechanism: Deep-blue metal-ion luminescence in aqueous solution
Iridium is not the only metal that Dr Oh-e has been investigating to understand its deep-blue luminescence. He has been interested in a different luminescence mechanism using the hydrated cerium cation, a rare earth metal cation. In hydrated cerium cations, where water molecules are connected to the cerium ion, absorption of light drives movement of the electrons within the metal ion resulting in deep-blue luminescence with very high yields. Understanding how hydrated cerium cations interact with various types of molecules is a question of fundamental chemical interest.
When positively charged cerium ions are in aqueous solution, they can form a range of complexes with other chemical compounds. Dr Oh-e and his colleague have found that when hydrated cerium ions are mixed with a carboxylic acid called diglycolic acid, an unusually strong and stable complex is formed between the two. The special type of interactions between the diglycolate and cerium, known as chelation, often has a large effect on the structure and electron distribution of the molecule.
Chelating compounds are frequently used as biological sensors as they bind a specific ion very strongly. Often, when that binding process occurs, this can have a strong perturbative effect on processes like the luminescence of the original molecule. Hydrated cerium ions are thought to be very bright emitters at wavelengths in the deep-blue region. However, cerium–carboxylate complexes become completely nonluminescent. This is a typical example that the electrons’ new pathways created by the metal-organic bonds disturb the original electron-route for luminescence.
Through Dr Oh-e’s systematic work on a number of hydrated cerium complexes with carboxylates, he has been able to identify the mechanism of the interactions between the ion and chelating species in solution, paving the way for new avenues in exploring how to understand and tune the deep-blue luminescence properties of molecules.
That’s all for this episode – thanks for listening, and stay subscribed to Research Pod for more of the latest science. See you again soon.